Fights in the southeastern carpathians, august 1917. In some ways, patton was as oldfashioned a figure as the united states could produce. But looking at the actual historical record, i have to question how this idea got started. Manfred rommel 24 december 1928 7 november 20 was a german politician belonging to the christian democratic union, who served as mayor of stuttgart from 1974 until 1996. Dec 20, 2009 british military historian terry brighton has written a biographical triptych of george patton, bernard montgomery and erwin rommel, three of world war ii s most colorful commanders. His father, erwin rommel 186019 was a math teacher, and later a secondary school headmaster at aalen. Ii corps under lieutenant general george patton in southcentral tunisia. Patton is shown having read a book, the tank in attack, by his adversary, erwin rommel. Erwin rommels most popular book is infantry attacks.
His battlefield manner was authoritative, his courage proven in the trenches of world war i when he was awarded the blue max. This incident results in his losing his commandand, by extension, missing out on dday. Patton 18851945, bernard montgomery 18871976 and erwin rommel 18911944 all served in world war i, impressed superiors and received severe wounds. Patton and erwin rommel were two tacticians that fought against each other during. Seventh army in the mediterranean theater of world war ii, and the u. Patton was among the many influential military leaders reported to have read infantry attacks. Oct 29, 2009 later editions are retitled infantry attacks. Despite his profane, posturing manner, and the sheer enthusiasm for conflict that made both his peers and the public uncomfortable, pattons very presence commanded respect. First, the prewar lives and background of these two men will be dissected. This may be so, but at least this cannot be said of erwin rommel, who. His orders were to hold ground in the saharan desert until hitler conquers. Mix play all mix american heroes channel youtube the third army in world war ii general george s patton 74682 duration. They both are nearly identical in the way they fought their fought their opponents erwin rommel was born in heidenheim then part of the german.
Next, the world war i contributions and exploits of rommel and patton will be compared and contrasted. Perhaps most famous for his commanding of the 7th army during world war ii, old blood and guts often gave rousing speeches to motivate, inspire, and educate his soldiers. Army could have claimed victory in berlin as early as november of 1944. Patton and erwin rommel were two tacticians that fought against each other during some of the crucial battles during the world war ii the world war ii featured some of the most brilliant tacticians in the history of war. Written by german field marshal erwin rommel, it was first published in 1937 as a journalesque chronicle of the author s experiences in world war i and the lessons he learned there. Jan 29, 2014 i have decided to write my paper over two of the greatest generals of world war ii. His strict discipline, toughness, and selfsacrifice elicited exceptional pride within his ranks.
These two men are the most well known generals of world war ii and for a reason. At the time, rommel was fighting the british in egypt. Most of what was to be in the tank in attack can be found in the book the rommel papers, which is made from notes and diary entries by field marshal rommel during the africa campaign. An eyewitness account of patton s interrogation of a ss general. The movie shows general patton reading field marshal rommel s book on tank warfare, which he never got a chance to complete. Patton usa vs general erwin rommel nazi germany battle of the legendary generals, all rounds are with ww2 technology and given 1 week of prep beforehand except for chess. He entered the army in 1910 and rose slowly through the ranks.
He had carefully studied the early blitzkrieg campaigns against poland and france and shared the conviction of the wehrmacht commanders that that a war of. L ocated near the german border, the city of metz had a population of about 100,000 in 1944 and was an important transportation, communication and administrative center. Erwin rommel has 17 books on goodreads with 12334 ratings. Patton and erwin rommel were two tacticians that fought against each other during some of the crucial battles during the world war ii. Furthermore if the author had included quotations from the printed books or. Rommel was born in heidenheim, germany, 45 kilometers 28 mi from ulm, in the kingdom of wurttemberg which was then part of the german empire, on november 15, 1891. The son of a wealthy southern family, he trained as a cavalry soldier and served in the usas last real cavalry campaign in mexico. Rommel brilliantly commanded an armored division in the attack 1940 on france. Aug 14, 2015 incensed by what he considers a slacker, patton smacks the poor soldier and orders him to get well in a hurry.
Both of them commanded brilliant, magnificent and impressive operations during the war. Men of war of the twentieth century were unorthodox. Patton, sensing victory as he peers onto the battle field from his command post, growls, rommel, you magnificent bastard. The book panzer greift an was however never finished by rommel. Titled infantry attacks, it was about fighting the italian army during world war i.
Patton, montgomery, rommel navy general library program. The book, patton and rommel men of war in the twentieth century by dennis e. Rommel and his art of war was written by erwin rommel and the description says. Buy patton vs rommel book online at best prices in india on. And while many history books focus the attention to hitler and allied. All suffered through two decades of peace, yearning for another war and continuing to impress those in command who could tolerate their egotism. Patton over the years there have been a number of military men who have led this nation on the front lines, but when these men come to mind, none stand out quite like general george s. Founded in 1997, has become a leading book price comparison site. Aug 22, 2008 what is considered the definitive book on erwin rommel. Patton was a complicated military figure, but there can be little debate over whether he was quotable. Patton 35 movie clip rommel, you magnificent bastard 1970. Both combat commanders, as described and assessed in dennis showalter s highly readable patton and rommel. Because of his great competence as a battlefield commander, patton. American, canadian and british forces are placed in the correct positions as the allied advance started to bog down.
Erwin rommel books list of books by author erwin rommel. Patton vs rommel kindle edition by cora, a download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. The following pages will examine the life, views, and military history of german field marshall erwin rommel and fourstar general george s. George patton, bernard montgomery and other top allied generals likewise expressed. Patton 35 movie clip rommel, you magnificent bastard. Patton, old blood and guts george smith patton is a very famous american because of his contributions in both world war i and ii. Rommel is set in and around the normandy beachhead shortly after the dday invasion of june, 1944. A dual biography of the two world war ii generals who changed warfareand historyforever.
Patton and erwin rommel before, during and after wwi and wwii. Patton and field marshal erwin rommel were masters of. This incident results in his losing his commandand, by. Rommel s policies were described as tolerant and liberal, and he was one of the most popular municipal politicians in germany. Apr 05, 2005 the book, patton and rommel men of war in the twentieth century by dennis e. Thriftbooks sells millions of used books at the lowest everyday prices. I keep running across the idea in movies and books that patton and rommel were archnemeses like batman and the joker. This war started in 1939 with the invasion of poland by hitler. Army officer who was an outstanding practitioner of mobile tank warfare in the european and mediterranean theaters during world war ii. Infantry attacks infantry attacks is a classic text in the field of military strategy. General george patton interrogates a ss general, 1944.
Erwin rommel simple english wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. The book clearly takes its place in the school of the allies won the war, but the. Rommels family lacked much of a military tradition. Patton, guderian, rommel three great tank commanders of wwii. Patton iii was a highly successful and highly controversial general who held corps and armylevel commands during world war ii. Incensed by what he considers a slacker, patton smacks the poor soldier and orders him to get well in a hurry. We personally assess every books quality and offer rare, outofprint treasures. Erwin rommel was one of german s most popular generals during world.
General patton was a united states military officer who was best recognized for his leadership during the second world war. In the film of the same name patton declares to have read the rommel book. O f the allied world war ii generals, george patton may be considered the most german. What is considered the definitive book on erwin rommel.
1237 911 792 148 1094 370 583 844 524 623 282 1493 1002 322 825 844 611 378 189 625 554 484 158 475 570 508 152 520 785 1108 506 1023 600 1291 760 77 683 563 255 751 185 1460 843 737 71